A majority of American
adults do not know that humans evolved from animal species or that the
Sun and Earth are in the Milky Way galaxy. And one-third think that
humans and dinosaurs existed at the same time, according to a new
nationwide survey on scientific literacy among adults.
The
survey, conducted by Louis Harris & Associates and the American
Museum of Natural History and released yesterday, found that despite
years of efforts to improve science education in public schools,
American adults possess a low level of literacy in science.
"The
message here is clear and simple," said Ellen V. Futter, the museum's
president and a former president of Barnard College. "Americans do not
know enough about science or the scientific process."
The
survey portrayed an adult population with such a limited understanding
of science that only 21 percent of the 1,225 adults questioned scored
60 percent or better on 20 questions that examined basic knowledge of
subjects that included space, earth, the environment, animals and
causes of diseases. 'Erratic' Grasp of Science
In assessing
the findings, Ms. Futter said American adults "seem to have an erratic,
almost idiosyncratic" understanding of "bits of science information."
The
respondents seemed to score best on questions with an immediacy in
today's world. A vast majority, 78 percent, knew that AIDS is caused by
a virus. And, questioned within weeks of the last California
earthquake, most respondents knew that the continents move.
But more than half did not correctly answer a question on evolution that was asked in these two different ways:
*Human beings developed from earlier species of animals, true or false?
*Human beings evolved from earlier species of animals, true or false?
Forty-six percent said false to both. The survey did not address whether religious beliefs might have affected the result.
Sixty-five
percent did not know how many planets are in the solar system, and only
a fraction, 10 percent, could correctly name what scientists believe to
be the nearest modern-day relative of Tyrannosaurus rex from a list of
four: chicken, crocodile, elephant and lizard. (It is the chicken.)
The
survey was conducted by telephone in February and March and had a
margin of sampling error of plus or minus three percentage points.
The
findings are similar to other specialized surveys of what Americans
know, like one on geography two years ago sponsored by the National
Geographic Society and one last year on knowledge of economics.
And
last September, a sweeping study by the United States Department of
Education concluded that a large percentage of the American adult
population has large gaps in basic knowledge, from an inability to read
at all to an inability to read a utility bill. Results to Help Museum
Ms.
Futter said the museum would use the survey's results to better tailor
the museum's science education classes for adults and children alike.
She said she hoped the findings would also be used by community
colleges and science organizations to fine-tune existing science
education curriculums or begin new efforts to address results that Ms.
Futter and other museum officials called "surprising," given the flow
of resources into science education into public schools since the 1957
launching of Sputnik by the former Soviet Union.
She and
other museum officials said schools alone should not be blamed for the
low level of science literacy. Although a four-year study released last
October by the American Association for the Advancement of Science
called for better curriculums and improved teaching, American students
continue to lag behind European and Asian students in achievement
tests, a trend that not surprisingly surfaces in the adult population.
Chart:
"QUIZ: Testing Scientific Literacy" shows how a national sample of
1,225 adults answered various questions on a test of scientific
literacy. (Sources: Louis Harris and Associates, The American Museum of
Natural History)